top of page

Official Herd Mentality Rules

Here's a breakdown of the rules for Herd Mentality: The Udderly Hilarious Board Game, also known as "Herd Mentality: Moo-velous Party Game":


  • Game Board depicting a farmyard with a paddock area

  • Question Cards with silly prompts

  • Answer Sheets for each player

  • Pencils or writing utensils

  • Cow Tokens (enough for all players to collect eight)

  • Pink Cow Token (one only!)

  • Die (optional, used in some variations)


  1. Place the Game Board:  Unfold the board and place it in the center of the playing area.

  2. Prepare the Paddock:  Place all the cow tokens face down in the designated paddock area on the board.

  3. Shuffle the Question Cards:  Mix the question cards well and place them face down within reach of all players.

  4. Answer Sheets and Pencils:  Distribute an answer sheet and pencil to each player.


The game follows a round structure with simple steps:

1. Round Start:

  • The youngest player starts the game and becomes the "Cattle Wrangler" for the first round.  This role simply means they'll be responsible for reading the question card aloud.

  • In subsequent rounds, the Cattle Wrangler role passes to the player to the left.

2. Ask the Herd:

  • The Cattle Wrangler picks the top card from the deck and reads the question aloud to all players. These questions are designed to be silly and prompt humorous answers.

3. Think Like the Herd:

  • Players have a short time to ponder the question and secretly write down their answer on their answer sheet. The key is to think like the "herd" and guess what answer most other players will choose.

4. Moo-ve it or Lose it (Reveal Answers):

  • All players simultaneously reveal their answers.

5. Scoring the Round:

  • Moo-ve it!:  If a player's answer matches the most common answer (or a close variation), they win a cow token from the paddock and place it in front of them.

  • Udder Nonsense!:  If a player's answer is unique and no one else has the same answer, they don't score a cow token this round.  However, some versions might award a point or some other benefit for a unique answer (check your specific game's instructions).

  • The Pink Peril!:   If all players except one have the same answer, the odd player out receives the dreaded pink cow token! This pink cow token prevents that player from winning the game until they can get rid of it.

6. Passing the Herd (Next Round):

  • The round ends, and the Cattle Wrangler role passes to the next player in turn order.

  • Shuffle any discarded question cards back into the deck if needed.

Optional Rule (using the Die):

Some versions of Herd Mentality include a die that can be used to add a bit of unpredictability. Before revealing their answers, players can roll the die. Depending on the number rolled, it might affect scoring or introduce some other silly twist (consult your specific game's instructions for details on die mechanics).

Winning the Game:

The first player to collect eight cow tokens and avoid having the pink cow token in their possession wins the game and is declared the "Top Cowpoke"!

Tips and Strategies:

  • Think Herd, Not Heard: While being completely unique might not always get you points, avoid overly obscure answers that no one else is likely to choose.

  • Pay Attention: Observe what other players might be writing down during the reveal phase to get a sense of the popular answers. This can help you adjust your strategy in future rounds.

  • Embrace the Silliness: Herd Mentality is a lighthearted party game. Don't take it too seriously, have fun with the silly questions, and enjoy the laughter along the way!

Herd Mentality is a light-hearted game that rewards players for thinking like the group. It’s perfect for parties and gatherings, as it encourages laughter and discussion.

This post contains affiliate links. For more information, see our disclosures here.

Browse Related Games!

bottom of page